Episode 268

full
Published on:

2nd Jul 2025

Elmer Gantry (1960) ft. Shoot the Flick

Dana and Tom are joined by first-time guests, Frankie and Scott (Shoot the Flick), to discuss another Best Picture nominee from 1960 with Elmer Gantry - celebrating its 65th anniversary: written and directed by Richard Brooks, cinematography by John Alton, music by Andre Previn, starring Burt Lancaster, Jean Simmons, Arthur Kennedy, and Shirley Jones.

Plot Summary: Based on a novel by Sinclair Lewis, Elmer Gantry's story follows the titular character (Burt Lancaster), a charismatic but morally dubious traveling salesman who uses his charm and persuasive skills to infiltrate the world of evangelical revivalism. He joins forces with Sister Sharon Falconer (Jean Simmons), a passionate preacher, and together they build a thriving religious movement. However, Gantry's past and his self-serving nature threaten to unravel everything, leading to dramatic consequences.

Guests:

Frankie Sparks

Scott Eisenberg

  • Co-host of Shoot the Flick

Chapters:

00:00 Introduction and Welcome to Frankie and Scott

00:46 Cast for Elmer Gantry

03:01 Why Elmer Gantry? Relationship(s) to the Film

07:01 Why Does Elmer Gantry Start with a Warning Label?

08:50 What is Elmer Gantry About?

19:08 Did Dana Like the Film?

20:08 Did Burt Lancaster Deserve His Oscar?

26:55 Background for Elmer Gantry

28:13 Plot Summary for Elmer Gantry

28:59 Did You Know?

36:28 First Break

38:21 What's Happening with Frankie and Scott?

42:22 Best Performance(s)

01:01:39 Best Scene(s)

01:15:02 Second Break

01:15:43 Best/Funniest Lines

01:18:47 The Stanley Rubric - Legacy

01:23:22 The Stanley Rubric - Impact/Significance

01:27:49 The Stanley Rubric - Novelty

01:36:27 The Stanley Rubric - Classicness

01:45:25 The Stanley Rubric - Rewatchability

01:55:01 The Stanley Rubric - Audience Score and Final Total

01:58:10 Remaining Questions for Elmer Gantry

02:02:55 Thank You to Scott and Frankie and Final Thoughts

02:06:14 Credits

You can also find this episode in full video on YouTube.

You can now follow us on Instagram, Twitter, YouTube, or TikTok (@gmoatpodcast).

For more on the episode, go to: https://www.ronnyduncanstudios.com/post/elmer-gantry-1960-ft-shoot-the-flick

For the entire rankings list so far, go to: https://www.ronnyduncanstudios.com/post/greatest-movie-of-all-time-list

Keywords:

Elmer Gantry, Burt Lancaster, false prophets, religion, film analysis, classic cinema, character development, cultural context, Oscar winners, movie history, charisma, best scenes, indelible moments, humor, legacy, classicness, rewatchability, Richard Brooks, Andre Previn, Jean Simmons, Shirley Jones, Arthur Kennedy

Ronny Duncan Studios

Show artwork for Greatest Movie Of All-Time

About the Podcast

Greatest Movie Of All-Time
Finding the Greatest Movie Ever Made
Hosts Tom and Dana Duncan take a new approach to finding the answer to the question: "what's the greatest movie of all-time?" Each week, Dana and Tom will review a classic movie, and grade it out based on a six-part rubric scale to determine what the greatest movie of all-time is.

For the complete list so far, go to: https://www.ronnyduncanstudios.com/post/greatest-movie-of-all-time-list

To contact us, please email the show at Greatestalltimemoviepodcast@gmail.com
Support This Show

About your host

Profile picture for Thomas Duncan

Thomas Duncan